1/8/2023 0 Comments Lilypond vs code![]() In exchange, they (we) get an extremely versatile package used by hundreds of thousands of other users, ranging from students and educators to professional musicians and publishers. The target Finale user is willing to spend up to $600 on a very specialized software product. Both products are targeted at musicians that notate, but with some differences. The most important measure of the project’s success is the satisfaction of the existing users and developers.Īudience. If you find something that doesn’t work you can report the bug, and if nobody wants to fix it fast enough you can attempt it yourself. They gradually improve the program and give it all away for free, including the source code. LilyPond, on the other hand, is Free Software written by volunteers in their spare time. They write the code, plan the new features, and fix the bugs. Generally, selling a product implies not giving it away, so the internals of Finale are kept a secret. Therefore, their decisions are based on business conditions and they measure their success in sales. They want to make an excellent product, but they need to sell that product so they can pay their staff and stay in business. Finale is a commercial software product written by full-time developers. In both cases, the most visible features are caused by the elements beneath the surface.Īs I see it, there are five major differences between LilyPond and Finale, which layer on top of each other beginning at the most fundamental and working up to the surface: Simply listing a few obvious functional differences, for example, would be like pointing out the contours of the human body without studying the underlying layers of muscle, ligament, and bone. Therefore, the amount of insight offered by any comparison depends very much on the depth of that comparison. I expect that most of this comparison would probably apply to Finale’s competitors as well, but I don’t know enough about them to make any specific comments.īoth Finale and LilyPond exist to place the standard elements of Western musical notation on paper, but apart from this objective they are fundamentally different. I will probably use both programs for some time, but the comparison has been so interesting that I wrote down what I thought. Now that I have tried LilyPond and gained some basic skill, I am stunned by how well it works. I am a reasonably contented Finale user, but I was very curious to see if LilyPond, a free music engraving program, had developed to the point where it would meet my needs. ![]() Here are some of my thoughts about the two programs and music notation. What happens when someone tries LilyPond after using Finale for years? Well, in my case I now like both programs, but for different reasons.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |